Water for Coffee – What do you need to know?

Coffee is 98.75% water. Why aren’t we talking about water chemistry more?

It’s not crazy to wonder what water chemistry is best suited for coffee brewing. Like all things coffee though, there isn’t a singular answer.

Question: I have a question regarding water used to brew coffee. I am a home coffee roaster and also a homebrewer of beer. Since water is the primary component of both beer and coffee it would stand to reason that the effects of water chemistry could be important to both.  Example: The best pilsner beers usually have water chemistry adjusted to be similar to the city of Pilsen in the Czech republic where the style began. Also, hop forward beers usually have a higher sulfate to chloride ratio so gypsum is a common addition to an IPA brewing water.
Is there any water chemistry profile that brews a better cup of coffee?  Could it be specific to the coffee origin? Brighter coffees work best with a water chemistry different from a rich Indonesian? Has anyone even looked at this? Am I crazy? I realize this question could head off into the esoteric weeds but if we are trying to brew the best cup I figure we should use the best water. 
Thanks, Bob

Reply : It absolutely does make a difference especially in perceived acidity. And it makes a difference when peoples water source is extreme in one way or other; extremely hard water or extremely soft. Different waters extract differently for sure as well. Water for coffee matters.

We check our soluble solids and have played around with chemistry. We’ve even tested some products that are supposed to optimize water for coffee. That is compounds that you add to distilled water. But these didn’t seem especially effective, and since in the bay area we have pretty nice water by default, it didn’t seem like something to pursue. If I live somewhere with an extreme water, especially soft water, I wouldn’t be using tap that’s for sure.

Just like there isn’t one single “world’s best coffee” or one “correct brew method” for coffee, I don’t think there is a single best water chemistry profile. It’s going to depend on taste, and as your email states, it’s about pairing a water and a coffee to reach a certain goal. There’s also simply the subjectivity of taste, as well as the cost of adding yet another variable, yet another thing to think about, when just trying to make a cup of coffee.

Some people are going to want to take this on, the people who brew on a scale and weigh their water as well as their ground coffee. Others are going to want to bonk you on the head for over-complicating something that should be simple, like brewing a cup of coffee! I am sort of split between the two sides here. I like to have the information, but it’s unlikely I would actually do the work of checking or adjusting water chemistry when brewing at home, since I already like what I get from minimally filtered tap water.

Bob, your question inspires a more in-depth answer, so expect an article here in the Coffee Library soon. I realize we haven’t addressed this aspect at all – amazing! And no, you aren’t crazy.

Here’s the book on the subject: 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.